Legal

Wisconsin Lemon Law: Four Repairs or 30 Days in the First Year, Form MV2691, and 36 Months to Sue

Under Wis. Stat. 218.0171, a new vehicle bought or leased in Wisconsin is a lemon if the same defect isn't fixed after four tries, or it's out of service 30 days or more, in the first year and under warranty. How to make the claim on WisDOT form MV2691, the refund and replacement deadlines, the mileage deduction, arbitration, and the 36-month limit to sue.

This page mentions companies BestWisconsin has a business relationship with. How we make money

Classic sedan parked on a street in Kenosha, Wisconsin
Classic sedan parked on a street in Kenosha, Wisconsin. Photo: CZmarlin — Christopher Ziemnowicz, a photo credit would be appreciated if this image is used anywhere other than Wikipedia., CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

A rattle in the dash is annoying. A new car that stalls at intersections and keeps coming back from the dealer “fixed” is a legal problem, and Wisconsin has a law for it. The Wisconsin Lemon Law, Wis. Stat. 218.0171, lets the owner of a new vehicle demand a refund or a comparable replacement from the manufacturer when a serious defect can’t be repaired [1][2].

The law is strict about timing and paperwork, and so should you be. Here’s how it works.

At a glance

Covers
New cars, trucks, motorcycles, motor homes and other registered motor vehicles bought, leased or delivered in Wisconsin [2]
The window
First year after delivery and before the warranty expires, whichever is sooner [1]
Lemon test
4 repair attempts on the same defect, or 30+ days out of service [1]
Claim form
WisDOT MV2691 (optional, but has required language) [2]
Refund deadline
30 days after you offer to transfer title [1]
Replacement deadline
Written agreement in 30 days, delivery by day 45 [1]
Mileage deduction
Price × miles at first report ÷ 100,000 (20,000 for motorcycles) [1]
Time limit to sue
36 months after first delivery [1]

Is it actually a lemon?

All of these have to be true [1][2]:

  1. It’s a covered vehicle. A new car, truck, motorcycle, motor home or other motor vehicle that must be registered in Wisconsin, including demonstrators and executive cars, purchased, leased or delivered here [2]. Vehicles bought out of state, or bought online and delivered outside Wisconsin, don’t qualify [2]. Mopeds, trailers, ATVs, UTVs, snowmobiles and boats aren’t covered [2].
  2. It has a real defect. The law calls it a “nonconformity”: a condition or defect that substantially impairs the use, value or safety of the vehicle [1]. Damage from abuse, neglect, or unauthorized modification doesn’t count [1]. WisDOT’s own example: an irritating rattle may not be enough; a vehicle that stalls or won’t run might be [2].
  3. You reported it in time. You reported the defect and made the vehicle available for repair before the warranty expired or within one year after first delivery, whichever came first [1].
  4. The manufacturer had a reasonable chance and failed. In that same window, either [1]:
    • the same defect was subject to repair at least 4 times and it continues, or
    • the vehicle was out of service a total of at least 30 days because of warranty defects. Days when repairs weren’t available because of a flood or other natural disaster, war, fire or a strike don’t count [1].

“Out of service” includes days the vehicle sits at the dealer for repair, and days it’s in your driveway but unsafe or unusable because of a defect the dealer has tried to fix at least twice [2].

The paperwork that wins these claims

Start a folder the first week you have trouble. WisDOT tells owners to keep [2]:

  • A repair order for every visit, even when the shop can’t find the problem or doesn’t try a repair. Each one should list what you reported and the dates the vehicle was in.
  • Your own log of the dates the vehicle was out of service and which defect caused it.
  • The purchase contract, the warranty and every other record of the purchase, repairs and service. Keep them in the house, not the glove box.

Making the claim

  1. Notify the manufacturer, in writing. The law requires you to tell the manufacturer the vehicle is a lemon and ask for a refund or a replacement [2].
  2. Use form MV2691. WisDOT’s Motor Vehicle Lemon Law form isn’t mandatory, but it contains language the law requires [2]. For vehicles purchased on or after March 1, 2014, MV2691 is the form; the old MV2694 is only for earlier purchases [3][4].
  3. Mail it to the manufacturer, not the dealer. The address is in your owner’s manual or warranty booklet [2]. Include the form, copies of all repair orders, and a cover letter explaining your situation [2].
  4. Send it certified mail, so you can prove the date the manufacturer received it [2]. Several deadlines run from that date [1].

WisDOT cannot resolve a lemon law claim for you; it can only explain your rights [2].

Refund or replacement: what the manufacturer owes

Wisconsin Lemon Law remedies
You chooseWhat the manufacturer must doDeadline
RefundFull purchase price, plus sales tax, finance charges, amounts you paid at the point of sale and collateral costs, minus a mileage allowance30 days after you offer to transfer title
Comparable new vehicleAgree in writing, then deliver it, and refund collateral costsWritten agreement within 30 days; delivery by the 45th day after receiving your claim
Replacement not delivered in timeFull refund with no mileage deductionIf the comparable vehicle isn't delivered by day 45
Heavy-duty vehicleSame choices on a longer clock120 days
Source: Wis. Stat. 218.0171; WisDOT Wisconsin Lemon Law guide (BVS2828) · Checked 2026-11-19

The mileage deduction can’t be more than the purchase price times a fraction: the miles on the vehicle when you first reported the defect, divided by 100,000 (or 20,000 for a motorcycle) [1]. For example, a $40,000 vehicle first reported at 5,000 miles: 5,000 ÷ 100,000 = 0.05, times $40,000 = a deduction of up to $2,000 (our math). Report problems early; every mile before that first report costs you.

A “comparable” replacement doesn’t have to be identical. The color may differ, but the trim level and options should be similar [2]. Either way, you hand back the lemon and sign over the title [1][2]. Leased vehicles have their own refund formula, and once you get a lease refund, nobody can enforce the lease against you [1].

If the manufacturer says no

  • Arbitration first, if it’s certified. If the manufacturer has an informal dispute program certified by WisDOT, you must use it before you can sue [1][2]. If its program isn’t certified, you don’t have to [2]. WisDOT describes arbitration as free, no lawyer needed, and you don’t have to accept a decision you don’t like [2]. WisDOT’s guide lists which manufacturers’ programs are certified.
  • Then court. You can sue for your losses, and a consumer who wins recovers costs and reasonable attorney fees too [1]. The case must be started within 36 months after the vehicle was first delivered to a consumer [1]. Lawyers who handle these cases know the fee rule; ask about it on the first call.
  • Don’t sign away your rights. Any waiver of your lemon law rights is void [1]. Heavy-duty vehicle owners are the exception to watch: WisDOT warns you can lose lemon law benefits for a heavy-duty vehicle by signing a negotiated written settlement [2].

This guide is general information about Wisconsin’s lemon law, not legal advice. If a claim is denied, or you’re close to the 36-month line, talk to a lawyer who handles lemon law cases. The State Bar of Wisconsin runs a lawyer referral service [2].

Sources

  1. Wisconsin Statutes § 218.0171: Motor vehicle warranties (Lemon Law)
  2. Wisconsin Department of Transportation: Wisconsin Lemon Law (BVS2828)
  3. Wisconsin Department of Transportation: Form MV2691, Motor Vehicle Lemon Law Notice
  4. Wisconsin Department of Transportation: Form MV2694, Lemon Law claim for vehicles purchased before March 1, 2014

Next steps

BestWisconsin has a business relationship with these companies, and we may earn money if you use them. How we make money

Credit repair company

Credit Saint

If an old debt or another item on your credit report looks wrong, Credit Saint can help you challenge it with the credit bureaus.

You can also dispute errors yourself, for free, with Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. No company can legally remove accurate, timely information, and results vary.

Learn about Credit Saint →

Free financial app

Bolster

Bolster is a free app for keeping an eye on your credit and building credit history over time.

Check the app's terms for any optional paid features.

See Bolster →

Credit monitoring and credit builder

Credit Squad

Credit Squad watches your credit and identity and alerts you to changes. Its credit builder, included with every plan, reports your monthly payment to all three credit bureaus as an on-time installment payment.

Paid monthly subscription; see Credit Squad's site for current plans and terms. Credit building depends on on-time payments, and results vary.

See Credit Squad →

Legal help by membership

LegalShield

LegalShield is a membership that gives you access to licensed attorneys for personal legal questions, like a landlord dispute, a small claims case or reviewing a document.

Monthly membership; what's covered depends on the plan and your state. We may earn a commission through our partner BestGuide.

See LegalShield plans →

Common questions

What makes a car a lemon in Wisconsin?

A new vehicle has a defect that substantially impairs its use, value or safety, and within the first year after delivery and before the warranty expires, either the same defect was subject to repair at least four times and continues, or the vehicle was out of service at least 30 days in total because of warranty defects.

How do I file a Wisconsin lemon law claim?

Notify the manufacturer in writing that the vehicle is a lemon and ask for a refund or a comparable replacement. WisDOT's form MV2691 is optional but includes language the law requires. Mail it to the manufacturer with copies of every repair order and a cover letter, ideally by certified mail.

How long does the manufacturer have to give a refund in Wisconsin?

30 days after you offer to transfer title for a refund. For a replacement, the manufacturer must agree in writing within 30 days and deliver by the 45th day after getting your claim, or else refund the full price with no mileage deduction. Heavy-duty vehicles get 120 days.

How long do I have to sue under the Wisconsin lemon law?

The lawsuit must be started within 36 months after the vehicle was first delivered to a consumer. If the manufacturer has an arbitration program certified by WisDOT, you must use it before you can sue.

See something wrong? Tell us

Every fact here links to its source. If something's wrong or out of date, tell us and the guide's reviewer will check it.

Keep reading